The Sheep Detectives (2026) Film Review

Rating: 4/5
A delightful and tear-jerking watch.

★★★★

👍 What works

• The sheep animation and characterisation

• The blend of humour and darker themes

• Strong creative team behind it

👎 What doesn’t

• Inconsistent visual tone in the environment

• Uneven human characters

• Tone may be too heavy for younger viewers

The Silver Hedgehog Rating: 'Recommended'

On a recent cinema trip, I spotted a trailer for an upcoming murder mystery film. It featured talking sheep, being tended to by Wolverine. Apparently, this wasn’t an ice cream induced hallucination and in fact, the film was real. As a lover of murder mysteries and sheep related nonsense I booked tickets.

There is a saying amongst film fans, “in Lord and Miller we trust”. That’s because Lord and Miller have produced and directed so many high-quality, fun family films with a specific blend of wit, charm, and visually dynamic direction. They have had a hand in films such as the Lego Movie franchise, through to the latest Spider-Man films. So as soon as their names came up on the opening credits as producers of The Sheep Detectives, I knew I was in for a treat, and seemingly so did everyone else. This is the first time in a long time that I found myself in a full cinema screen everyone had flocked to the cinema!

Script/Screenplay

The Sheep Detectives is written by Craig Mazin, another strong name attached to the film, who has adapted the story from the German novel ‘Three Bags Full’ by Leonie Swann.
Mazin is someone that is at home writing comedy (The Hangover), as well as writing darker storylines (The Last of Us), or exploring characters (Chernobyl). I wondered how he would get on with writing something for a much much younger audience.

We, the audience find ourselves in the English village of Denbrook where we meet Shepherd George (Jackman). George loves his flock and they love him too. He takes great care of the sheep, including reading them chapters from murder mystery books. Once George has gone to bed we find out that we can understand the sheep. They can talk (this sounds like Baaa-ing to humans). One morning George is found dead and the sheep decide that Lily, the worlds smartest sheep, must solve the murder*

** I wonder how Lily would get on with ‘Basil The Great Mouse Detective’?

At first glance, The Sheep Detectives appears to revolve around a flock of sheep solving a murder mystery. The bright summer countryside setting and playful humour create a light-hearted atmosphere. While the murder mystery plot is conventional, it is possible this is the first time younger viewers encounter the Means, Motive and Opportunity (MMO) framework, traditionally used in criminal investigations. This is a valuable point, as it could encourage children to develop critical thinking decision-making and risk evaluation as they talk and remember the film in weeks and months to come.

The murder plot as you mighty expect is very formulaic. A shepherd is found dead, a bumbling village policeman has to investigate the murder, there is a will involved and strangers arrive in the village this mirrors the plot of the books that George reads to his sheep.

As superficial as the murder mystery is, Mazin ensures the messaging goes deeper. Whilst solving the murder the sheep discuss what happens when a sheep dies, do sheep become clouds? and they come to grips with religion in their own sheepish way. The sheep discuss that a transparent shepherd made of bread, called God lives in a brick house and damns things…like a beaver. This truly is a very funny scene and was worth the ticket money alone. The story also deals with even darker allegories such as a literal black sheep of the family lambs and sheep being cast out for being born at the wrong time of the year. We also have sub plots involving a reporter who is trying to make a name for himself, instead of reporting obituaries. All this is set in an Americanised view of a typical English village.

The film goes in hard on death and exclusion themes, to the point that a large chunk of the films subplot is given to the ‘winter lamb’, we learn that lambs born in winter are often excluded and ignored by other sheep, which is what has happened to this winter lamb. So much so that the winter lamb hasn’t been given a name, other than, you guessed it…the winter lamb! We also meet a darker, older sheep called Sebastian that is very much a loner and has his own back story (we later learn that Sebastian is a ‘winter lamb’ as well). This theme continues into the human characters as we learn more about Georges family.

Cutting through the darkness, is a field load of humour, some visual, some spoken. Look out for a visual chicken crossing the road gag, and some very Hot Fuzz-style characterisations of village folk. Literally, the village sees George (Jackman) as the winter lamb, and he is very much the outcast. The vicar, butcher, and hotel owner all treat him with disdain.

Having attended a lot of village fetes and witnessed firsthand the sheer silliness and bonkersness of sheep (two sheep decided they weren’t going to participate in a sheep herding display and jumped the hay barrier straight into the crowd!) It’s great to see this translated onto the big screen. Mazin must be channeling Aardman as he captures the nuances of each sheep, giving them distinct personalities. There are serious sheep, like Sir Ritchfield (Patrick Stewart), intelligent sheep, Lily (Julia Louise Drefus), and young lambs bursting with joy and energy, like Zora (Bella Ramsey). Each sheep is meticulously written and clearly defined, all playing a crucial role in solving the mystery.

I am confused on one point though, much is made of the sheep forgetting things on cue, except for one. Is this a real thing? Do sheep willingly forget things for a reason, and why is one sheep a woolly Wikipedia?

I suppose though, that really doesn’t matter too much, as the sheep are genuinely the stars of the film, and the sheep scenes are so expertly written, that the human cast feel a little short-changed.

village fete escapee sheep

Cast

Here is our pick of casting.

Nicholas Braun as Officer Tim Derry

I understand this is a family film and needs some humour, but why must it come from a bumbling village policeman? Tim Derry seems like the village idiot, completely inept at law enforcement. Braun plays the fool perfectly, embracing the absurdity and maintaining his composure while interacting with the sheep. I’ll never understand how he managed that with a straight face. As the film progresses, we witness Officer Tim Derry’s journey of growth, culminating in Braun’s Peter Falk moment with the grand murder reveal. His performance remains consistent and well-cast throughout.

Hugh Jackman as George Hardy

In a clip I’ve seen, Jackman discusses reading the script, loving it, and signing on to the film. This is evident in his performance as George. The glint in his eye shows he’s thoroughly enjoying the character. His warmth and empathy for the sheep shine through, while his utter contempt for the locals displays the strength we’ve seen in his previous roles. One thing though, what’s with his accent? It sounds like he’s trying something, but what it is, I don’t know.

The voice cast…

I can’t mention the cast without a note on the Sheep Cast, a string who’s who of British talent. What I noticed is that the voice cast really acted well, embodying their own personalities. Patrick Stewart sounds like Patrick Stewart, in astute Picard mode. Brett Goldstein channels his best Roy Kent, with a gruff exterior and heartfelt moments, and Bella Ramsey’s sheep bears more than a passing resemblance of Bella.

🐑 Main Sheep Voice Cast

• Julia Louis-Dreyfus — Lily

• Bryan Cranston — Sebastian

• Chris O'Dowd — Mopple

• Regina Hall — Cloud

• Patrick Stewart — Sir Ritchfield
  

🐑 Additional Sheep Voices

• Bella Ramsey — (Zora)

• Brett Goldstein — (Ronnie and Reggie)

• Rhys Darby — (Wool Eyes)

Sound

The sound mix for the theatrical presentation is a standard 5.1, no fancy ATMOS here. Not that the film really needs such an expansive soundscape. The score is by Isobel Waller-Bridge and sounds excellent. I noticed that each sheep had a musical personality, such as Lily who tends to have a more structured melody vs Sir Ritchfield whose grand, slightly over-the-top version of classical, reinforced his self-importance.

The inclusion of the hit Proclaimers song 500 Miles is an odd choice. It doesn’t really fit with the narrative of the film, and the film does not appear to be set in Scotland. This was a Prime (get it!) opportunity to make an original song, or go for something obvious from The Worzels.

Video Quality

The cinematography beautifully blends naturalism with a touch of stylistic flair. The countryside scenes are beautifully framed with wide, open compositions that give the sheep plenty of space within the landscape. The depth of field is used cleverly, often focusing on the sheep while softly blurring the background— a subtle trick that helps the animated characters blend seamlessly into the real world. The camera movement is mostly gentle, which really suits the mood. However, the village design can be a bit jarring. Often, the camera shows neon signs for things like Police Station and Butcher shops, which I have never seen in a village like that before.

At its best, the film looks warm and welcoming; at its worst, it can feel a bit too polished.

Effects

The sheep animation is genuinely impressive. You can see individual hairs in the wool, the subtle flick of an ear, and even the detail in their curly coats and tongues, at times you half expect one of them to shake and send bits of fluff flying into the audience. It gives them a tactile, almost too real presence… which is slightly unsettling when they start talking about murder.

There’s also a strong sense of personality baked into the animation. Visual gags land consistently, particularly the sheep that always seems to be heading in completely the wrong direction to the flock. I laughed a lot when I saw one of the sheep on a swing .

Crucially, the sheep feel believable within the world. When placed alongside the human characters and dogs, they don’t feel like cartoon inserts, there’s real weight and movement to them. You buy them as actual animals… just ones who happen to have better deductive reasoning than most humans!

That said, the visuals aren’t flawless. Outside of key story moments, some environments drift into that slightly artificial “animation sheen.” Colours are bright— sometimes very bright— to the point where a few fields look less like the English countryside and more like they’ve been filtered through an overenthusiastic Instagram preset. It doesn’t ruin the experience, but it can momentarily pull you out of what otherwise feels like a carefully grounded world.

Overall Thoughts

The Sheep Detectives is a film created by a strong production team featuring an equally strong cast. It makes full use of the talent involved, creating a family film that does not shy away from its darker elements.

The opening mystery, involving the unexplained death of a farmer, is quite basic in the murder genre. The contrast between the gentle, child-friendly visuals and the grim subject matter is expertly handled and layered.

I do think that younger viewers may find some of the themes unsettling, particularly as the narrative grows increasingly preoccupied with mortality. The fact that the film confronts death quite bluntly may leave children questioning what they have been told about death, and whether this ‘family’ film is truly suitable for its younger audience. I’m thinking that it’s more for ages 7+.

The Sheep Detectives is ultimately a delightful and tear-jerking watch. It boldly combines happy, carefree sheep with the complexities of murder. The film lingers largely because it quietly unsettles viewers while still being incredibly fun.

The Silver Hedgehog Rating: 4.6 'Recommended'

The Script / Screenplay
🦔🦔🦔🦔 4/5
Casting

🦔🦔🦔🦔🦔 5/5

Music / Score

🦔🦔🦔🦔 4/5

Visual Effects and Costumes

🦔🦔🦔🦔🦔 5/5

Video Quality

🦔🦔🦔🦔🦔 5/5

It boldly combines happy, carefree sheep with the complexities of murder. The film lingers largely because it quietly unsettles viewers while still being incredibly fun.

Find out more about our ratingså

Words Garry
Editor JJ

Review Extras

You might like our other Comedy Film Reviews.

Support our website with a coffee.